Critical Race Theory Is a Hammer Looking for Nails.

In a racist society a racialized response to racism is to he expected. It will not, alas, bring an end to racism, rather reinforce it.

Critical race theory is an ideology in most senses of the word. But to attempt to personally exonerate (“white”) racism by allowing that it is not attitudinal rather systemic is vain. How can anything be systemic without involving attitudes?

Critical race theory is a hammer looking for nails. There are plenty of nails around, so no need to go turning every little nub into one.

Awareness of racism is but one tool among others, because, to adopt another piece of jargon, race is one among many intersections of the wider problem of class, caste and gender inequality.

*

Malheureusement, les idées de Foucault & Derrida (disons de #biopolitique & #deconstruction) se sont échappées en anglais pour devenir virulentes. Comme si le milieux français, où les abstractions prolifèrent, conférait une immunité contre la prise d’idées trop au sérieux [Tweeted on geogeoplots] 

As Adorable as They May Be

Children, adorable as they universally are, function as little germ factories with a suboptimal sense of personal space and hand hygiene.

– Anjana Ahuja FT 1-2 Aug. p 7

On cancelling Halloween: “I don’t think allowing lots of little hands to rummage through sweets would be a good idea.”

– Jamie Dowery Guardian 13 Sept

Sid Meier’s Memoir

I was a fan. Of video games. But that was back in the Pleistocene of the computer age.

I did get beyond Pong, all the way to Pac-Man, Bizarro and Tempest, the last my fav. But that was before the RNA of FRP (fantasy role playing) games infected that genre ;-).

At the same time I discovered something even more amazing: basic word-processing, which was then itself infected by HTML.
For a while I was absorbed with the possibilities of hypertexts. Wrote a couple of fortunately unsuccessful grant proposals to markup a corpus of writing in creole languages, create a data-base, etc.
Though I remained vested in Texts, I admit to having passed hours on Flight Instructor with a then young nephew of Nasrin’s, Bob / Babak. Also, used to play Super Mario with another adolescent son of a colleague in Edmonton. The adults would go off into another room and drink their beer.
*
On Sep 10, 2020, at 15:06, XX wrote:
Wow–cool!  The ghost-writing by your niece.  I didn’t know you were a fan of computer games.  I guess this is a bit sophisticated for my 12-year-old grandson, but he says he wants to be in the gaming world as a career!

*

On 2020-09-10 14:52, George Lang wrote:

I don’t know why I feel the atavistic urge to signal that my niece Jennifer Noonan ghosted Sid Meier’s (the inventor of Civilization) Memoir!

 

 

On Sep 10, 2020, at 15:06, XX wrote:

Wow–cool!  The ghost-writing by your niece.  I didn’t know you were a fan of computer games.  I guess this is a bit sophisticated for my 12-year-old grandson, but he says he wants to be in the gaming world as a career!

On 2020-09-10 14:52, George Lang wrote:

For these with a past or a present or an interest in computer games; myself, but the first. I don’t know why I feel the atavistic urge to signal that my niece Jennifer Noonan ghosted Sid Meier’s (the inventor of Civilization) Memoir!

 

Reading around Paul Beatty’s The Sellout

A thoughtful friend asked me what I was reading these days and her query I helped me to understand my path to Beatty’s The Sellout. Herewith some retrospective landmarks.

I am not usually a on-trend reader by I was without a doubt affected by #BLM to look again at black, or rather African-American writers, which I had always tended to neglect given my Africanist and then creolist and Caribbeanist orientations. My prejudice has been that African-Americans writers are too … American.

As I mentioned, I started with two thrillers with a black Texas Ranger protagonist by Attica Locke, Bye-bye Blackbird and Heaven, My Home (two of the Hwy 59 series).

Remembering the existence of Alain Locke, who is far from fashionable among BLMers, I asked my old backyard buddy Michael, who teaches at the historical HBCU Texas Southern U, if the contemporary writer Attica Locke was related to Alain Locke. Turns out probably not, she is the scion of a prominent black Houstonian lawyer and activist.

As reflected in the backstories of her thrillers, especially Heaven My Home, Attica Locke’s family is deeply and historically Texan, not likely to have gotten there swimming upstream, as it were, during the Great Migration north, especially since Alain Locke’s family was Philadelphian to point of having tinges of Quakerism in their ideals.

This and other features of Alain Locke’s bourgeois, Victorian background were mentioned in Jeffrey Stewart’s Pulitzer-Prized 900 pp bio, The New Negro, of which I finished 600 or so, reaching circa 1935. Maybe I’ll get back to it. Turns out that in my opinion it should be required reading not only in Black Studies, but also Queer Studies, since Locke was a major figure in what could be called Black Queer Studies, if anyone needs to create more disciplinary boundaries.

I also browsed in the anthology of Harlem Renaissance writers Alain Locke edited, The New Negro (https://www.amazon.com/New-Negro-Alain-Locke-ebook/dp/B00N5Y0SFU/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=The+New+Negro&qid=1598823648&s=digital-text&sr=1-1).

Reading and surfing therein and thereabouts I ran across Hokum: An Anthology of African American Humor: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002UM5BK0/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1.

Hokum was edited by Paul Beatty and I discovered an extract therein by Alain Locke’s contemporary Georges Schuyler (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Schuyler). Sky-ler.

Schuyler’s politics in the last part of his life (like those of Steinbeck, soit dit en passant) are not exactly my cup of tea, but I did discover that his Hokum-extracted book Black No More had a Broadway version planned until Covid came along (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_No_More). The book itself is a free-wheeling Swiftian parody which will obviously be shorn of the full spectrum of its satire if it does ever reach the stage. No sign of it yet. I’ve inquired.

There is I an clear affinity between Black No More and The Sellout, though I can’t find any commentary on this relation, one which I doubt Beatty would like to have bruited about, given the very bad odor Schuyler is in.

Schuyler was a contrarian. He also wrote a novel about Liberia and the modern day slavery practiced by the Americo-Liberians who had colonized it (Slaves Today, 1931) — facts of which I was aware having lived there 1967-1969.

He was also an ideological opponent of W.E.B. du Bois, arguing against “Negro Art Hokum“.

Schuyler’s 1929  pamphlet Racial Inter-Marriage in the United States  called for solving the country’s race problem through so-called miscegenation, then illegal in most states. A third big no-no.

As another black satirist, Ishmael Reed, observed: in the final years of Schuyler’s life, it was considered “taboo in black circles even to interview the aging writer”.

Beatty is absolutely no Schuyler, but I suspect that many folks, perhaps more white liberals than blacks, will find Beatty’s book offensive in its language and ideas. I found it bracing.

If they have to let Americans get the Man Booker, I’m glad it was him the first.

Cheers,

George

The erasure of differences between people through mimicry

I tend more to the fox than a hedgehog. René Girard, cast as the essential hedgehog, nonetheless appeals to me. 

No contradiction. The Many comprends the One. The only way the One can subsume the Many is by clumping them into a single set.

*

“It is not difference that dominates the world, but the obliteration of difference by mimetic reciprocity, which itself, being truly universal, shows the relativism of perpetual difference to be an illusion.

“This was, and remains, a pessimistic view of human life, as it posits a paradox in the very act of seeking to unify and have peace, since the erasure of differences between people through mimicry is what creates conflict, not the differentiation itself.”

At first it might seem Girard is alluding to what has become known as “cultural appropriation” but the seizure of the other runs much deeper than the rather superficial political idea associated with that phrase.

*

“With the Gospels, it is with full clarity that are unveiled these “things hidden since the foundation of the world” (Matthew 13:35), the foundation of social order on murder, described in all its repulsive ugliness in the account of the Passion.”

*

According to the philosopher of technology Andrew Feenberg: In La violence de la monnaie, Aglietta and Orléan follow Girard in suggesting that the basic relation of exchange can be interpreted as a conflict of ‘doubles’, each mediating the desire of the Other. Like Lucien Goldmann, they see a connection between Girard’s theory of mimetic desire and the Marxian theory of commodity fetishism. In their theory, the market takes the place of the sacred in modern life as the chief institutional mechanism stabilizing the otherwise explosive conflicts of desiring subjects.[22]

*

Tocqueville’s Democracy in America: “They have swept away the privileges of some of their fellow creatures which stood in their way, but they have opened the door to universal competition; the barrier has changed its shape rather than its position.”[33]